🧾 What Is the Social Contract, Really?

Dr. Chris Jones

May 13, 2025

By Dr. Chris Jones
In Good Faith With Dr. Chris Jones – Week 1, Part 1

You don’t sign it. You don’t carry it in your wallet. You might not have ever even heard it named.

But the social contract shapes almost every moment of your life.

It’s the agreement — often unspoken, always powerful — that says:

If I work hard, follow the rules, and show up, I should be protected. I should be heard. I should be treated fairly.

It’s the unspoken bargain beneath the surface — where playing by the rules is supposed to earn you safety, respect, and a fair shot.

But here’s the thing:
That deal has never been real for everyone. And right now, it’s cracking. With much of the cracking being done intentionally by bad actors.

📜 Where the Idea Comes From

The phrase “social contract” comes from centuries-old philosophy, but the concept is older than any textbook. It’s the foundation of how people live together in any society.

The idea is simple:

To live in a civil society, we agree to act a certain way.
We agree to stop at red lights, wear clothes in public, pay taxes, follow the law.
In return, we get order. We get protection. We get a shot at stability and justice.

The earliest Western political theorists put it into words:

Thomas Hobbes warned about life in a state of nature — nasty, brutish, and short — and said it’s better to live under agreed rules.
John Locke built on that, arguing that governments exist to protect life, liberty, and property — and that if they fail to do that, people have the right to change them.
Jean-Jacques Rousseau pushed further, saying that any government not based on the will of the people is illegitimate.

These ideas influenced America’s founding documents. They echo in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution.
And they show up in your everyday expectations — whether you name them or not.

When you believe the water that comes from your faucet should be safe to drink…
When you expect your child’s school to open on time, with heat and books and teachers…
When you cast a vote and expect it to count…
That’s the social contract at work.

The social contract isn’t one-size-fits-all — not across the globe, and not even across America. What one culture sees as a harmless gesture — like a thumbs-up — another might see as an insult. But the differences run deeper than gestures. In the Jim Crow South, the so-called social contract was written in blood and terror: where whiteness granted the power to insult, assault, or even lynch Black people — with impunity. That wasn’t just a breach of the contract. That was a system where violence was the contract — and justice was deliberately excluded from the deal.

❗ The Contract Wasn’t Made for Everyone

Even when the words of the contract appear clear and universal, the benefits aren’t equally distributed. Some people are excluded outright — by design. Others are excluded in practice — by interpretation, bias, or neglect. Sometimes the contract is drafted to leave people out. Other times, it’s applied in ways that deny them access. Either way, the result is the same: a promise on paper that fails in real life. Just look at the Founding Fathers.

When the Founders wrote “We the People,” they didn’t mean:

Enslaved Africans, whose labor built the wealth of this country but who were denied the most basic human rights
Indigenous nations, who were forced off their land and whose sovereignty was violated by broken treaty after broken treaty
Women, who were considered property and denied the right to vote, own land, or speak freely in public
Immigrants, who laid the railroad tracks, cleaned the homes, picked the crops — but were excluded from power
Poor white families, especially in rural America, who were told to be proud while being left behind

Even today, we see the fractures:

A rural town in Arkansas closes its only hospital — and residents must drive hours for emergency care
A Black family in Michigan lives off bottled water because their taps run poison
A student is punished for “talking back” in a classroom where they were just telling the truth

These aren’t isolated incidents.
They’re examples of a broken deal — a contract not just breached, but selectively enforced.

🔍 Why Talk About It Now?

You might be wondering — why talk about the social contract now? The answer is simple: there’s nothing more dangerous than a broken promise you can’t see. The social contract shapes our daily lives, yet it remains invisible. And what’s invisible often holds the most power.

If we don’t name it, we can’t challenge it.
If we can’t challenge it, we can’t change it.
And if we can’t change it — we’re left living under a set of rules we never truly agreed to.

Right now, trust in American institutions is crumbling — and not by accident. People feel unheard, unsafe, and unseen. Scratch the surface of that frustration, and you’ll find something deeper: a broken agreement, a promise made but never kept.

And here’s the truth: there are people in power right now who aren’t just ignoring the social contract — they’re actively trying to dismantle it. Not reform it. Not renegotiate it. Destroy it. And in many cases, they’re succeeding.

That’s why this conversation matters now — not someday, not after the next election — now.

This conversation matters now because it’s possible that the contract needs to be re-written.

People believed in the deal. They followed the rules.
They gave their loyalty.
And what they got back was school closings, poisoned water, closed clinics, rigged maps, and empty promises.

That’s not a contract. That’s a con.

🧾 What Is the Social Contract, Really?

Discussion about this post